Welcome to Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant
Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, located at 1910 Lincoln Way E in Guilford, PA, offers an inviting atmosphere combined with remarkable culinary creations. Patrons laud the freshness and flavor of the dishes, from their delicious pizza to mouthwatering subs. Customers remark on the attentive service and reasonable prices, making it a beloved choice for both locals and travelers. Despite the quiet dining area on some evenings, the food’s quality shines through, with rave reviews praising the cheeseburger subs and pizzas. With a commitment to delightful dining experiences, Benny's has quickly become a favorite for many, ensuring a return visit is always in order.
Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings
Currently sitting in the dinning room. I was kinda nervous as we were the only people in the dinning area. Especially on a Friday night it’s hard to find a place that isn’t jammed packed full of people. I’m not sure why this place isn’t full. The food was absolutely delicious. 10/10 recommend. We will be back!
Fantastic food! Each meal that was ordered was fresh and delicious. Will return again for sure!
As a traveler passing through I took the chance of visiting Benny's for a cheeseburger sub and fries. Both the fries and cheeseburger sub were on point and delicious! As a Disabled man I highly appreciate them bring my order out to my van, Thank you and I am ever in the area again you will have a repeat customer.
First time trying this place with my wife. We really enjoyed the food and the service was really good. We will definitely be coming back.
My wife and I absolutely love this place. We recently moved to Chambersburg and we're looking for good pizza places around here. We tried Benny's a few weeks ago and fell on love with their subs and pizza. The staff is very friendly, the food is so flavorful, and the prices are reasonable. This has become our new favorite pizza and sub shop. I can't say enough great things about them. Every time you bite into a sub you can literally taste the freshness of all the ingredients.
I’ve been here twice now for lunch. Good service, food is pretty solid. Gladly will come back again.
Our first visit to this restaurant was delicious! I ordered the manacotti with salad and bread, and couldn't eat it all that was served. There restaurant side is so clean and cozy. The take out side is separate to eliminate traffic. I liked that idea. Try it out. The smell of Italy cuisine will make your belly growl.
Good take out. Quality of dining in has slipped since the pandemic.
Location
-
1910 Lincoln Way E, Guilford, PA 17202, United States Hotline: +1 717-263-0422
Welcome to Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant, a hidden gem located at 1910 Lincoln Way E, Guilford, PA. If you're in search of authentic Italian cuisine accompanied by mouthwatering pizza, look no further. This establishment, though sometimes quiet, offers a burst of flavors that will leave you craving more after your first visit.
Reviewers like Marissa Lowans have been pleasantly surprised by the quality of food, describing it as “absolutely delicious” and giving it a perfect 10/10 recommendation. Such high praise reflects the careful attention to detail that Benny's takes in every dish. Whether you're sitting down for a hearty meal or opting for their takeaway, the freshness of the ingredients is unmistakable.
Admiral Kirk echoes this sentiment with his experience of delightful meals that are both fresh and flavorful. At Benny's, every plate tells a story of dedication, from perfectly baked pizzas to generous subs that cater to all tastes. The cheeseburger sub, noted by traveling customer Joe, is a standout, perfectly accompanied by crispy fries, showcasing the variety of options available beyond traditional Italian fare.
For couples and families looking for a welcoming dining experience, many have expressed that Benny's is their new favorite spot. Rob B and his wife found themselves enamored with the flavorful subs and reasonably priced meals, proving that Benny's is not just an eatery, but a community hub where you want to return time and again. The friendly staff adds to the inviting atmosphere, making you feel like part of the family.
So, if you're in the Guilford area—whether a local or passing through—Benny's Pizza & Italian Restaurant beckons with the promise of memorable meals that share the essence of authentic Italian cooking. Indulge in their offerings, enjoy the cozy ambiance, and discover why this restaurant deserves a spot on your culinary radar.